OUR FANHOUSE TOOLBAR INTEGRATES THE LATEST SPORTS NEWS INTO YOUR WEB BROWSER AND INSTALLS IN SECONDS.
YOU CAN DOWNLOAD THE TOOLBAR HERE.

FanHouse 2008TrainingCampBattles

Latest 2008TrainingCampBattles Stories

49ers Training Camp Battle: David Baas vs. Tony Wragge vs. Chilo Rachal

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

Forget what you hear about there being a battle at quarterback for the 49ers. Alex Smith will be under center when the season begins, and it doesn't matter how 49ers fans feel about it.

That being said, right guard is truly a competition. There wouldn't be if 2005 second-rounder David Baas wasn't recovering from torn pectoral muscles. But Baas' pectorals are, in fact, torn, and it's doubtful (though possible) he'll be ready for the beginning of the season.

So veteran Tony Wragge will compete with rookie Chilo Rachal for the right to start for at least the season's first game. Rachal is the more talented of the linemen, and the 49ers invested a second round pick in him this year, but Mike Nolan has admitted that it'd be tough for a rookie to win a starting job on the line right away. Still, the 49ers briefly tried Rachal at right tackle, so they're obviously looking at him to play sooner than later. It's possible a strong camp wins him the job.

And depending on the performance of whoever's been holding the fort, as well as the team in general, Baas might have to fight to get his job back. Offensive lines thrive on continuity, and if the team's offense finds a groove (for the first time in forever), it might be tough for Nolan to make a switch.

Of course, assuming the 49ers offense will find a groove is getting far ahead of myself.

Rams Training Camp Battle: Brett Romberg vs. Mark Setterstrom

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

The Rams' offensive line was destroyed by injuries last year. They hope that additions in free agency and the draft will improve the unit's overall talent and depth, but they're pitting two of the players hurt last year -- Brett Romberg and Mark Setterstrom -- against each other at center.

Romberg is a natural center out of the University of Miami who was the starting snapper for nine of his healthy games last year. Setterstrom has never played the position before, starting his career as a left guard, but the team sees a lot of promise in the 24-year-old and wanted to find a spot for him after signing Jacob Bell to fill that spot this year.

Setterstrom is also significantly bigger, with two inches and almost 20 lbs. on Romberg. That's a significant difference in a division with a lot of big-bodied defensive tackles.

After last season, it'll be a nice problem to have two capable centers on the roster. And if this season's anything like last, they'll both be needed. In the end, the Rams need to just let the best man win and hope that guy stays healthy for all 16, depth or no depth. For Marc Bulger's sake.

Dolphins Training Camp Battle: John Beck vs Josh McCown vs Chad Henne vs ...

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

Under Bill Parcells, the Miami Dolphins are trying to get younger and build from the ground up. There are battles going on everywhere. However, the most impactful (with the most attention) will be the starting quarterback ... where there are three Dolphins fighting for the job.

The candidates are John Beck, Josh McCown and Chad Henne.

Of the three, Henne is the longest shot. He has the least experience and is looked at more as a long(er) term project. He would have to impress mightily to win the job when the season starts, though he may have his shot later in the season.

So, it really breaks down to Beck and McCown. Beck was looked at as the future when he was drafted in the 2nd round last year. Well, that was under a different regime and before Beck looked shaky last season. Still, if Miami is really trying to develop for the future, Beck seems to be a no-brainer*. He seems to have the coaching staff leaning his way and spending a lot of time working with him.

Josh McCown is the most experienced, albeit, not as exciting. The team knows what it will get out of McCown but also knows that he isn't the long term answer at the position. McCown could win the job just because they want a steady presence in the huddle and running the offense which will help further develop everyone else.

Jaguars Training Camp Battle: The Receivers

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

One could argue that the Jacksonville Jaguars' Super Bowl aspirations bounced off Dennis Northcutt's hands last January. David Garrard completed 64% of his passes last season, but it seemed like it should have been much higher, because the Jaguars' receivers dropped so many passes. That's just one reason why this team spent $30 million on Jerry Porter.

That said, Porter will miss the preseason while recovering from hamstring surgery, so its up to the remaining receivers to show that they know how to catch -- which might seem like a tall order when photos like this and this keep popping up. Those photos, however, didn't stop the Jags from taking a flyer on Troy Williamson, who reportedly looked great in minicamp. Still, that was minicamp. How will he fare in actual games?

Reggie Williams' job might be the safest after his breakout season last year. Despite catching only 38 passes, he had career highs in yards per catch (16.6) and touchdowns (10), and he has the size every coach loves. He and Porter are projected to be the starters.

So what other targets does Garrard have?

Falcons Training Camp Battle: Matt Ryan Vs. Chris Redman

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

As you would expect with a team that is coming off a season that could best be described as a train wreck combined with a earthquake topped off by a nice little forest fire just to make things tidy, the Falcons have a lot of wide-open starting jobs as training camp begins.

They'll be looking to see if second-round pick Curtis Lofton is ready to take over at middle linebacker, which would allow Keith Brooking to move back outside. They'll be watching disappointing Michael Jenkins to see if he can outplay the unhappy carcass that once was Pro Bowler Joe Horn. And we'll have to see if rookie Sam Baker is ready to step in and start at offensive tackle.

But the battle that will define the Falcons 2008 season will be the quarterback competition. If Chris Redman starts more than eight games this year, it either means that the Falcons are playing much better than expected, or that the offensive line is such a disaster that 0-16 seems possible.

Vikings Training Camp Battle: Aundrae Allison vs. Robert Ferguson

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

It says something about the Vikings roster that one of the biggest battle during this year's training camp will be for the No. 4 receiver job. The reality is that besides a lot of drama about Brett Favre and the quarterback situation, there aren't many positions where Minnesota doesn't have a clear starter.

And even more encouragingly, there's some pretty good depth at several spots. Chester Taylor is one of the best backup tailbacks in the league. Second-round pick Tyrell Johnson gives the team an excellent back-up safety, and Jared Allen's acquisition means that Brian Robison goes from being an every-down starter to a very useful backup defensive end.

Titans Training Camp Battle: Four-Way Battle For Starting Wide Receiver Jobs

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

For a team that is now built around its franchise quarterback, the Tennessee Titans sure don't do a lot to help him out.

The day the Colts drafted Peyton Manning, they already had Marvin Harrison. But they also made sure that they gave him other targets. Between Brandon Stokley, Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark, Manning has always had a plethora of quality pass-catching options.

Tom Brady may not have had Pro Bowlers at wide receiver until Randy Moss and Wes Welker showed up, but between David Givens, Deion Branch and Troy Brown, he always had a set of very reliable targets.

Panthers Training Camp Battle: Tyler Brayton v. Charles Johnson v. Stanley McClover

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

The Carolina Panthers go into training camp with several key positions on the line. Muhsin Muhammad, D.J. Hackett and Dwayne Jarrett are all fighting for the chance to start with Steve Smith at wide receiver. Rookie Charles Godfrey and free agent acquisition Terrence Holt will likely compete for the free safety spot. The right guard competition is full of big boys -- Keydrick Vincent, Toniu Fonoti, and Milford Brown weigh a combined 1000 pounds -- who look like they could out-eat Joey Chestnut. (Looks can be deceiving, of course.)

Perhaps the most closely watched position battle in Spartanburg this year, though, will be the defensive end battle. The Panthers lost much of its once-potent pass rush last year when Julius Peppers fizzled and Mike Rucker looked less-than-fully recovered from knee surgery in 2006. Rucker is retired, while Peppers will try to prove last year was an anomaly.

So who starts opposite from Peppers?

Packers Training Camp Battle: Brett Favre vs Ted Thompson

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

Trust me, I didn't want it to be this way.

However, the truth is that Green Bay's biggest battle during training camp will be the ongoing saga between Brett Favre and GM Ted Thompson.

Pretty much every starting job is set. Justin Jolly's arrest for codeine possession and his injured rotator cuff has all but handed the defensive tackle jobs to Justin Harrell and Ryan Pickett. There could be a fight for the left guard spot ... but who are we kidding? It's all Favre, all day.

I'm not going over what has happened (click here to catch up on it all), but this thing will come to a head sometime during training camp. It has to. Heck, in just a few weeks this thing has looked like center court at Wimbledon. One of three things will happen: Favre will be practicing in green and gold; Favre will be traded/released or Favre will stay retired.

Colts Training Camp Battle: Mike Pollack vs Charlie Johnson

Training camp is finally here and FanHouse breaks down the most important position battles heading into the season, team by team.

Despite playing center at Arizona State, the Colts insist that second round pick Mike Pollack will play guard for them this year.

And there is an opening. Long time starter Jake Scott has left for the Tennessee Titans and Indy needs a new right guard. Right now, the battle is between Pollack and third year player Charlie Johnson. Johnson is a converted tight end and backed up rookie Tony Ugoh at left tackle last season.

The problem here is that neither Johnson or Pollack are guards by trade. Johnson struggled with speed ends last season, so a change should do him well. Pollack played center at ASU but will be asked to move over a spot.

Right now, put your money on Pollack. He is extremely athletic for an interior lineman and is a punishing pass blocker. He fits the mold of what the Colts want from their offensive linemen. Johnson may end up being that utility guy that can be thrown in anywhere if there is an injury issue.

Of course, Pollack could end up at center down the road. Current center Jeff Saturday is on the downswing of his career and may see Pollack as his eventual replacement.

Featured Writers

Featured Voices