Andy Marte is supposed to be the starting third baseman for the Cleveland Indians. Supposed to be. The problem is that so far in camp, Marte hasn't been getting the majority of the starts at third.
Casey Blake has started 3 games at third, and combined with Hector Luna, Mike Rouse, and Keith Ginter, the quartet has started 8 games at the hot corner. Marte has started only six.
Blake is slotted to be in a platoon at first base with Ryan Garko and Victor Martinez, yet he's spending more and more time at third while Travis Hafner has started three games at first. If the Indians are giving Hafner chances at first base that's a very strong sign that they are seriously considering moving Blake to third base.
All of which makes you wonder what the team is going to do with Marte. Marte struggled last season with a .226 average and a paltry OBP of .287. To his credit, Marte improved over the last month and a half hitting .267 with 5 home runs and 21 RBI, but privately the Indians still aren't convinced. He's shown he can hit the fastball, but is absolutely baffled by breaking balls away. If the Indians have noticed this, you can be sure the rest of the Majors have too, and Marte shouldn't expect to see a lot of fastballs when he's at the plate.
Even Marte's defense is coming into question. He has good hands and a very strong arm, but he hasn't shown enough range to be considered a superior defensive third baseman. What that means is if Marte isn't going to be a Gold Glove caliber defender, he's going to have to hit a lot more to warrant playing time.
Until then, it seems that except for centerfield and a lesser extent shortstop and second base, the entire Indians lineup will be a platoon.