
While the University of Cincinnati continues to investigate the reports of
sex, alcohol and videotape for a recruiting visit that was made public by way of an anonymous letter last week;
rumors of the incident had been floating around for a couple weeks in the training-room.
University of Cincinnati athletic department officials were notified for the first time Feb. 8 of allegations that four UC football players and four recruits engaged in sex acts with a former women's soccer player during a recruiting visit.
"That was the first time anybody was officially notified that people felt like this was anything more than a training-room rumor," UC senior associate athletic director Mike Waddell said Monday.
According to Waddell, on that day, two student-athletes informed Maggie McKinley, director/compliance and student services, of rumors that there had been a party in a residence hall at which the incidents are alleged to have taken place.
...
McKinley's first response was to phone the training room to verify the extent of the rumor. Later that afternoon, she met with Bob Arkeilpane, deputy director of athletics, to inform him of the allegations. Arkeilpane then met with football coach Brian Kelly and subsequently with UC athletic director Mike Thomas.
Following the meeting with Thomas, Arkeilpane, McKinley and Kelly met together to discuss the allegations. Kelly then called in some football players to ask them what they knew about the allegations.
It would appear that the timeline runs in this way: the athletic department started a series of meetings that included the athletic director (AD) and to discuss the rumors -- presumably with issues of investigation, verification, punishment and contatinment. That led to Coach Brian Kelly calling in some of the football players. Almost immediately after these meetings the letter (PDF) was sent to the University president and the local papers that made this public that cast the meetings in quite a different light.
The story by the athletic department is that as soon as they got wind of the hint of a problem they began investigating the situation. They met to figure out who might be involved, and what steps should be taken to investigate, including talking to some of the football players and trying to establish the truth or otherwise of the stories.
The other view is that the athletic department, as soon as they heard about it, began meeting and planning on how to cover up the incident. That the conspiracy reaches through the compliance director, the Deputy AD, the AD himself, and of course, the football coach. The football coach then called in some of his players and put them on notice to seek and destroy any and all evidence.