
That's the question a lot of pundits are asking today in trying to figure out how the Saints, preseason NFC favorites, are 0-2. But the magic they're referring to is that annoying, mythical "Katrina magic" that people invented last year. That's not what I'm referring to. Last year was based on a lot of really good personnel decisions, good coaching, and inspired play. We know that good coaching and inspired play have so far been nowhere to be found. But what of the personnel decisions?
Last year, the Saints had a magic touch shaping their roster. They got four starters in the draft (
Roman Harper,
Jahri Evans,
Marques Colston, and
Reggie Bush), six if you include draft-day trades for
Jeff Faine and
Hollis Thomas. They also made smart moves in free agency; besides
Drew Brees, the team also got outsized contributions from
Scott Shanle,
Terrance Copper, and
Scott Fujita. Almost every move they made turned to gold.
This year? Meh. Only four picks (
Usama Young,
Jermon Bushrod,
Andy Alleman, and
Robert Meachem) have made the team, all but Young have been deactivated for both games, and he only plays sparingly. Their dabble in free agency has been worse.
Eric Johnson has been average at tight end, but at least he's doing
something; it goes downhill from there.
Kendrick Clancy won a starting job at defensive tackle but has been blah.
Jason David's exploits are well documented.
Kevin Kaesviharn has looked lost at nickel safety. And linebacker
Brian Simmons can't beat out
Mark Simoneau, who couldn't shed a block by
Holly Mangold.
There's a lot of problems that need to be fixed with this team, and it's unfair to attack the new guys when so many of the holdovers have been so, so awful. Still, the Saints added a lot of players in the offseason, and counted on those players to improve the team. They haven't.