On the DL since April with a bum shoulder, Gustavo Chacin was unceremoniously plucked out of his AAA rehab stint by Jays management last week and optioned to the minors. The thinking here, Jays GM JP Ricciardi explained, was that being optioned would give Chacin ample opportunity to get a lot of starts under his belt without any pressure or deadlines.
Major League Baseball, however, smelled a rat, and voided the option.
The reason? MLB suspected that the Jays sent Chacin to the minors to try to squeeze another year out of his contract.
Chacin was victimized, whether on purpose or not. The 26-year-old entered '07 with two years and 14 days of major-league time. If he's on the DL under an injury-rehab assignment, he is gaining major-league time. The free-agency clock is ticking. If he's optioned in good health, no service time accrues.
If the Jays hadn't been asked to void the option on Sunday, they could have left him in the minors until Sept. 1 or beyond, some 35-plus days of time lost. He would then have finished the season with less than three years of major-league time, at around two years and 150 days. Good for the club, bad for the player.
Intentional or not, a manuever like this could tarnish the Jays' rep among players and potentially harm their future chances of landing prized free agents. Seems like a high price to pay for another year of Chacin's services.