
Last year, the Chargers used their second-round pick on left tackle
Marcus McNeill and was arguably the league's best rookie, although I imagine
Vince Young might disagree. McNeill did a splendid job of protecting
Philip Rivers' blindside and opening holes for
LaDainian Tomlinson on San Diego's way to a 14-win season.
Fast-forward to 2007 and it's a completely different story. According to the
San Diego Tribune's Kevin Acee, McNeill has allowed 9.5 sacks this season compared to just five in '06. (The Chargers have tagged McNeill with six in 2007 and two in 2006; either way, he's been less consistent in pass protection this season.)
So what gives? General manager A.J. Smith, in between trying to rationalize why firing Marty Schottenheimer was the right move,
says McNeill "has struggled, but not each and every game ... he's been having trouble in a couple games with outstanding pass rushers."
Among the [other] reasons he is not the protector he was is he has too often been technically messy or even slow. Also, teams have had almost two seasons to see him, understand where he is vulnerable, when he is prone to leaning over or not getting leverage or being sloppy with his footwork. Additionally, some opposing ends are more hyped up to play him than when he was relatively unknown.
That might explain why Tennessee's
Kyle Vanden Bosch was running roughshod over McNeill for most of the game last week. To McNeill's credit, he rallied in the fourth quarter, contained Vanden Bosch, and the Chargers somehow managed to win in overtime. It wasn't pretty, but whatever gets the job done, I guess.