
The Magic improved by 12 games this year to finish with 52 wins, their most since 1996 when Shaquille O'Neal and Penny Hardaway carried the team all the way to the NBA Finals. GM
Otis Smith deserves a lot of credit for the turnaround, first for bidding against himself to sign
Rashard Lewis and then having the foresight of knowing
Tony Battie would get suffer a season-ending injury to open up playing time for the soon-to-be Most Improved Player
Hedo Turkoglu. For that, he was
rewarded with a three-year extension.
Am I being a little harsh? Perhaps, but Smith is obviously riding the coat-tails of
Dwight Howard's ascension to superstardom. Sure,
Stan Van Gundy turned out to be a nice pick to coach this team, but he's only there because Smith's first choice,
Billy Donovan, flaked out. And is anyone really excited about
Jameer Nelson's future? Smith gave him a five-year, $35 million contract last summer, but he couldn't even hold down a starting job for all of last year.
Wouldn't a talented young point guard like
Rodney Stuckey have been a nice replacement? Well, Smith gave the Pistons Orlando's 2007 first-rounder used to select Stuckey in the
Darko Milicic/
Carlos Arroyo trade. Darko lasted just a year and a half before leaving town while Magic fans are counting down the days Arroyo's contract comes off the books this summer. And don't even get me started about drafting
JJ Redick ...
Smith is hardly the worst GM in the league, but I'm convinced the Magic are where they are despite his efforts, not because of it.