After Sunday's home victory against Atlanta, I began to wonder if the Lions defensive line would have done as well containing Falcons QB Michael Vick had DT Shaun Rogers been able to play? As valuable as Rogers is to the Lions, the move of DE Cory Redding to defensive tackle in Rogers' absence appears to have been fortuitous, at least in Sunday's game.
Rogers, who is one of the more athletically gifted defensive tackles in the NFL, has been heavily criticized for his lack of a consistent work ethic. Rogers also has a less then congenial relationship with the local media. Rogers has assumed a stronger leadership role among the defensive linemen in the locker room this season, even if it is not necessarily a positive one. His leadership has lead him to prevent the team's other defensive linemen from commenting about their performance to the local media. I realize that a professional athlete is not any more beholden than anyone else is to comment to members of the media, yet, as poor as the Lions have performed in recent years the media can also be a valuable ally for a struggling team (i.e. spin control).
Rogers' four game suspension came as a result of him taking a substance that contained ephedra (or one of it's derivatives), which he was using to help maintain his body weight, something he has often struggled with. Rogers has an incentive-laden contract that prescribes that he meet certain weight requirements, so that he receives more money if he maintains his weight. In effect, Rogers put his weight issues and receiving his full salary ahead of making sure that he would be available to the team by choosing to take the banned substance. Rogers has stated that the death of Hall Of Fame DT Reggie White (due to sleep apnea, which Rogers also has) contributed to his concerns about his weight and eventually lead him to decide to take the banned substance.
Whether it was carelessness or selfishness Rogers' absence has cost the team. Since Rogers' suspension, the Lions have been without DT Shaun Cody and also have recently placed DE James Hall onto injured reserve. This lack of depth increases the likelihood that later in games, with increased playing demands, the Lions defensive line wil be less effective.
The emergence of Cory Redding as a quality defensive tackle gives the Lions a little more leverage to apply in their expectations of Rogers. I don't believe he will be allowed to start immediately upon arriving back from his suspension. The Lions are going to be able to demand a higher, more consistent level of effort from Rogers. The Lions may also be the recipients of a more pliable, humble attitude from Rogers. You would hope that Rogers would be exceedingly hungry to be get back onto the playing field after missing five weeks of football.