
There's nothing better than writing about something we can all disagree on. That's basically what ESPN has turned into between 5pm and 7pm EST every night. Just people with differing opinions bantering back and forth. With these noble ideas in mind, here's my list of questionable All-Star Selections.
Griping about All-Star selections -- It's one of those odd New Year's resolutions we all manage to miraculously keep year in and year out. These players are good, but they're not All-Stars in my mind. At least not this year. And if you don't like it, look on the bright side, tomorrow there will be a post on the most well-deserving players.
Questionable selection #4 - Jason Arnott
OK, what is this... 1996? This is only Arnott's second All-Star Game and he's not as big a name as he once was, but this selection is actually only mildly questionable. You can look at it as a guy who's only going because he's the only representative from his team. You can also look at it as a guy who at 33 is having the best season of his career.
Questionable selection #3 - Manny Legace
There's no doubt this guy is having a great year. The problem is, there are quite a few goaltenders in the West having better years. Two of them are in the ASG (Osgood, Nabokov) and one backed out (Luongo). Still, it's hard to believe that
Pascal Leclaire, who already has seven (YES, SEVEN) shutouts and
the Dominator did not make it past Legace. But I'm all for giving guys their due, and Legace certainly deserves his share.
Questionable selection #2 - Eric Staal
Granted, being selected only factors in on-ice accomplishments, but Staal's run-in with the law this summer is unbecoming of an All-Star. Not something we want our kids to look up to and that whole bit. This story came to the forefront and then went out back and died in the quietest and quickest way possible. That's to say that there really wasn't a big deal made out of it... It's hard to pick at Staal's numbers with almost a point per game, but he does have an ugly -7 +/- rating.
Questionable selection #1 - Scott NiedermayerIs this guy a great defenseman? Absolutely. Did he win a Cup last year? No doubt about it. But what has he done for me lately? Nothing. He left his team hanging for almost half the season while he debated retirement. As good as he is, there's no Niedermayer in team. In my opinion, 17 games doesn't cut it. He's been good since he has been back (2G, 9A) but I think this would have been an honor better fitted for someone who didn't, how do I say this,
bail on their team for almost half the season. Not to mention he's the fourth Duck on there, none of which were voted in.