
The Pittsburgh Penguins' loss to the Senators in the first round showed how experience often triumphs over youth. While Sidney Crosby was great, the other youngsters, especially Marc-Andre Fleury and Evgeni Malkin, were not.
It's no wonder why the Penguins are eager to retain the services of old guys
Mark Recchi and Gary Roberts for next season.
"(Penguins' GM) Ray (Shero) has had conversations with Gary and Mark Recchi, who's also a free agent, about coming back," says new Penguins' front office member Chuck Fletcher. "They feel as if the environment we created this season was very good, and Gary got swept up in it a little bit. He enjoyed playing with the young players and sees a bright future for the organization."
Gary Roberts was so hell-bent on not going anywhere but Toronto/Ottawa at the trading deadline before relenting on going to Pittsburgh. I'd be surprised if he was THAT swept up in the organization to choose them over returning 'home' to Ontario. Roberts is exactly the type of player Pittsburgh needs: gritty, battle-hardened, and experienced.
Roberts, for all of his positives, is 41 and has troubles staying healthy. If he's going to play any sort of hardball with negotiations, the Penguins ought not to bother.
Mark Recchi, on the other hand, purposely went back to Pittsburgh after his tenure with the Flyers, and seems to love playing there. Even at the age of 39, Recchi was still very productive (albeit thanks to Sidney Crosby being the fountain of assistful youth) with 68 points last year. I just worry about his defensive liability issues and the fact that his playoff performance (4 assists in 5 games) left something wanting.
If I were a betting man, I'd bet on Roberts playing elsewhere and Recchi coming back to the Penguins to finish his career.